Is a Free Roof Inspection a Scam? What Texas Homeowners Should Know

We get it — the roofing industry has trust issues, and a lot of them are earned.

If you typed "is a free roof inspection a scam" into Google or skimmed the Reddit threads before landing here, you're doing exactly the right thing. After every hailstorm in Dallas, Fort Worth, Plano, Frisco, Austin, Richardson, or Sherman, neighborhoods get flooded with trucks, door knockers, and yard signs from companies nobody has heard of before. Some are fine. Some are running the oldest playbook in the book.

This post is the honest version of that conversation — written by a roofer, about roofers. We'll tell you what a legitimate free inspection actually is, the red flags that should make you close the door, and the questions that separate real contractors from storm chasers. We're also a stranger to you, so we'll tell you how to check us out the same way you'd check anyone else.

First — no, a free roof inspection is not automatically a scam

In Texas, free roof inspections are standard practice, and there's a real economic reason.

Texas has some of the highest hail frequency in the country. DFW sits in the middle of what insurers call "hail alley." Most roof replacements here aren't paid out of pocket — they're paid by homeowner insurance after a storm event. A contractor who wants your business has to get on your roof to see if there's claim-worthy damage before anyone writes a quote. Charging for that inspection would price them out of the market.

So the "free" part isn't the scam. What matters is what happens during and after the inspection. That's where the industry splits in half.

Why storm chasers exist (and why they're in Texas right now)

After a major hail event, out-of-state crews show up within 48 hours. They rent short-term lodging, register a shell LLC, print truck magnets, and go door-to-door. The math is simple — they want to sign as many contracts as possible before the good local contractors get booked up, collect insurance money, slap on a roof fast, and move to the next state before any warranty issues surface.

Some of those crews do decent work. Many don't. The common denominator: when something goes wrong in year three, the phone number is disconnected and the LLC is dissolved.

This isn't theoretical. After the March 2016 Wylie storm, the 2019 Dallas tornado, and essentially every Austin hail event since 2018, the Texas Attorney General's office and local news outlets ran story after story about homeowners left with leaking roofs and no one to call.

Red flags — if you see these, shut it down

1. They knocked on your door unsolicited after a storm. Not all door-knockers are bad, but the overwhelming majority of serious trust issues start here. Legitimate local contractors rarely need to canvass. They have referrals, reviews, and returning customers.

2. They're pressuring you to sign an Assignment of Benefits (AOB) before the inspection. An AOB transfers your insurance claim rights to the contractor. Once you sign, they control the money, the scope, and the timeline — not you. There is almost no scenario where a homeowner benefits from signing an AOB at the front door. Texas has tried to reform AOB abuse multiple times for a reason.

3. "We'll cover your deductible" or "we'll eat the deductible." This is illegal in Texas under Insurance Code § 27.02. Offering to waive or rebate a deductible is insurance fraud, and it exposes the homeowner to fraud liability too. Any contractor who says this is telling you, in plain English, that they break the law. Believe them.

4. They want a big deposit before any materials are on site. A small material deposit can be reasonable on a cash job. On an insurance job, most of the money flows from the carrier to the homeowner in stages — there's no reason for a contractor to need thousands up front. Deposits that disappear along with the contractor are a classic exit scam.

5. No physical local office you can drive to. A PO box, a cell phone, and a truck magnet is not a business. A local address, a long operating history, and online reviews that go back several years are the minimum.

6. Can't produce manufacturer certifications. GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster — these certifications require training, insurance, and a track record. They're not required to install a roof, but their absence on a contractor claiming to be "top rated" is a signal.

7. Quotes without measuring. A real quote comes from a real measurement — either a roof walk or an aerial report (EagleView, Hover, etc.). A number pulled out of the air in your driveway is marketing, not pricing.

8. "We can only hold this price if you sign today." Legitimate pricing doesn't expire in four hours. That line exists to shut down your ability to get a second opinion.

Green flags — what a trustworthy free inspection looks like

• The inspector actually gets on the roof (weather permitting) and spends real time up there — 30 to 60 minutes on an average home.
• They come back down with photos. Lots of photos. Close-ups of hail impacts, granule loss, soft metal dents on vents and flashing, mat exposure — the actual evidence an adjuster will want to see.
• They walk you through what they found, including what is not damaged.
• They're willing to say "you don't need a new roof." That sentence, from a roofer, is the single strongest trust signal in the industry.
• The written report includes the address, date, inspector name, measurements, and photo documentation — not just a marketing flyer with a phone number.
• They don't ask you to sign anything binding that day. A free inspection should be free, full stop.

Questions to ask any roofer offering a free inspection

1. How long have you been operating in Texas under this company name?

2. What's your physical office address?

3. Can I see your certificate of general liability insurance and workers' comp?

4. Which manufacturers have certified you, and at what level?

5. Do you have references from homes within 10 miles of mine?

6. What's your warranty, and what company backs it?

7. If my insurance denies coverage, what happens next?

8. Will you put in writing that you will not offer, rebate, or absorb any portion of my deductible?

If a contractor hesitates on any of these, you have your answer.

What an inspection should actually include

A complete inspection should document:

• Field damage — granule loss patterns, hail impact density per square, mat exposure, thermal splits
• Accessories — soft metal on vents, gutters, downspouts, window wraps, and A/C fins (collateral damage supports a hail claim even when the shingles look borderline)
• Flashings and penetrations — step flashing, chimney counter-flashing, pipe boots, skylight pans
• Ventilation — intake and exhaust, whether current setup meets code and manufacturer warranty requirements
• Decking condition — any sag, rot, or separation visible from accessible areas
• Prior repairs — mismatched shingles, tar patches, signs of previous claim work

And it should end with a clear recommendation. Replace, repair, or leave it alone. Not "call your insurance tomorrow" as the default answer regardless of what's up there.

How Square's process works

We're a Richardson-based company with a second location in Sherman. We've been doing this long enough that most of our work comes from referrals and repeat customers, not door knocking.

Here's the plainspoken version of what happens when you call us:

1. We schedule a time. A real appointment, not "we're in the neighborhood right now."

2. We inspect. An experienced inspector gets on the roof and documents everything with photos and measurements. Usually 45 minutes to an hour.

3. We tell you what we found. If there's no claim-worthy damage, we say so. If there is, we show you the photos and walk you through what an adjuster will likely see.

4. You decide whether to file a claim. Your insurance, your decision. We don't file it for you, and we don't want AOB rights.

5. If you file, we attend the adjuster meeting. We bring our documentation, walk the roof with the adjuster, and make sure damage isn't missed. We don't negotiate on your behalf — that's a public adjuster's job, and we're not that.

6. Once the scope is settled, we schedule the work. Written contract, clear deductible language, manufacturer-certified installation, and a warranty that's backed by a company that will still exist in ten years.

That's it. No high-pressure close, no AOB, no deductible games.

You can read about us at /about, see how we run free inspections at /free-inspection, read our approach to insurance claim work at /insurance-claims, and look at real customer reviews at /reviews.

FAQ

Are all door-to-door roofers scams?

No. But the base rate of problems among door-knockers in Texas after a storm is high enough that we'd treat it as a default red flag unless proven otherwise. Ask for credentials, check reviews, and never sign anything at the door.

What's an AOB and should I sign one?

Assignment of Benefits transfers your insurance claim rights to the contractor. Almost no homeowner should sign one. Square doesn't ask for AOBs.

Is it legal for a roofer to pay my deductible?

No. Texas Insurance Code § 27.02 makes it illegal for a contractor to waive, rebate, or absorb a homeowner's insurance deductible. Any offer to do so is a crime the contractor is proposing to commit with you.

Does a free inspection obligate me to anything?

It shouldn't. A legitimate free inspection is free whether or not you hire the contractor for repairs. If there's paperwork involved at the inspection stage, read every line before signing.

Should I file an insurance claim every time there's a storm?

No. Filing a claim that's denied can still affect your premium and claim history. That's why the inspection matters — you want a professional opinion on whether there's actually claim-worthy damage before you call your carrier.

How do I check a roofer's reputation in Texas?

Google reviews, BBB (with a grain of salt), Nextdoor, manufacturer certification pages (GAF, Owens Corning publish their certified contractor lists), and the Texas Secretary of State's business entity search to confirm the company actually exists and has been around.

What if I already signed something I shouldn't have?

Texas law gives you a three-day right of rescission on most home solicitation sales, including contracts signed at your door. The clock starts when you sign. If you're inside that window, put the cancellation in writing and send it certified mail. After three days, a lawyer may still be able to help depending on the contract language.

How is Square different from a storm chaser?

We have a physical office in Richardson, a second location in Sherman, a track record in DFW and Austin, manufacturer certifications, and a phone that will be answered five years from now when a warranty question comes up. You don't have to take our word for it — verify all of that before you hire us.

---

The short version: a free roof inspection in Texas is not inherently a scam, but the industry has enough bad actors that skepticism is the correct default. Ask hard questions, refuse to sign anything the same day, and walk away from anyone who pressures you on a deductible or an AOB.

If you want a straight answer about your roof after the latest storm, schedule an inspection or call us at 214.621.7376. If you don't need a new roof, we'll tell you.